Struggling with a Difficult Employee? Try This First.

When a high-performing employee becomes resistant, defensive, or disengaged, it's easy to focus on the behavior that's causing problems. But what if understanding what's driving that behavior is the key to helping them grow?

Enrich recently welcomed Dr. Doug Gardner, an Enrich member and performance psychology expert with decades of experience working with elite athletes and high-performing teams, for an interactive workshop on Leading with Empathy: Creating Space for Teams to Learn and Perform.

Drawing on lessons from professional sports, behavioral research, and real-world leadership challenges, Doug explored how leaders can better understand the pressures their teams face, recognize the behaviors that emerge under stress, and create environments where people feel supported in growing.

The session also featured an engaging peer discussion, with Enrich members bringing their own leadership challenges to the group and working together to explore new approaches.

Here are some of the key takeaways.

 

Every day is game day for your team.

In professional sports, athletes may spend 80% of their time practicing and only 20% performing.

In the workplace, that balance is almost reversed.

Employees are expected to deliver results while simultaneously learning new skills, adapting to changing expectations, and navigating unexpected challenges.

With AI accelerating the pace of change, that pressure is becoming even more pronounced. Employees may find themselves questioning skills they've spent years developing, struggling to keep up with new technology, or feeling uncertain about their value.

Dr. Doug emphasized that stress isn't inherently negative, but leaders need to recognize how it affects behavior and performance.

When someone struggles, the question shouldn't just be whether they're performing. It should also be what pressures might be affecting their ability to perform.

Resistance isn't always a lack of willingness.

One of the most valuable discussions emerged when an Enrich member shared a challenge involving a highly capable employee who consistently delivered results but resisted collaboration and sharing knowledge.

The group explored several possible explanations for this behavior.

Was the employee overwhelmed? Protecting their sense of ownership? Worried about becoming less valuable if others learned their work? Or simply uncomfortable relinquishing control?

Doug explained that behaviors we interpret as stubbornness, disengagement, or unwillingness to collaborate can sometimes be protective responses to uncertainty or perceived threats.

That doesn't mean leaders should excuse problematic behavior. But understanding what might be driving it can help them choose a more productive response.

Before reacting to someone's behavior, get curious about what's behind it.

Empathy doesn't mean avoiding difficult conversations.

Leaders still need to establish expectations, address performance issues, and hold people accountable.

But how they approach those conversations can make an enormous difference.

Doug introduced a concept he calls "structureless structures."

The idea is to have a clear goal for what needs to change without imposing so much structure that the other person immediately becomes defensive.

Rather than demanding an immediate answer or commitment, leaders can introduce an idea, ask a thoughtful question, and give someone time to reflect.

A simple phrase like "I'd like you to think about this" can create space for a more productive conversation later.

During the peer discussion, members also explored how understanding individual motivations and creating opportunities for shared ownership could help a resistant employee become more collaborative.

The goal is to make people partners in solving the problem rather than making them feel like the problem themselves.

Confidence comes from competence, not the other way around.

Doug highlighted an important relationship between confidence, competence, and effort.

People often avoid working on things they're not good at because trying and failing can feel more threatening than not trying at all.

This is especially relevant in technology organizations, where experienced professionals may suddenly find themselves navigating unfamiliar tools, responsibilities, and expectations.

When someone feels that their expertise is being challenged, disengagement or resistance can become a way to protect their sense of competence.

Leaders can help by creating opportunities for people to practice, make mistakes, and recognize their own progress.

As Doug explained, once people begin improving at something they previously struggled with, that progress can become its own motivation to keep learning.

The goal isn't to make people feel confident before they begin. It's to help them build confidence through growth.

Sometimes the smallest leadership moments make the biggest difference.

Empathetic leadership doesn't always require a lengthy coaching session or a formal development plan.

Sometimes it starts with noticing someone's effort, acknowledging that a challenge is difficult, or asking a question without expecting an immediate answer.

Doug encouraged leaders to become more aware of their own reactions before responding to someone else's behavior.

One of his guiding principles was:

"Self-awareness leads to self-correction."

When leaders recognize their own frustration or assumptions, they create an opportunity to respond more thoughtfully.

And when employees feel that their effort and progress are being noticed, they're more likely to feel supported as they work through challenges.

The bigger question: Are you reacting to behavior or understanding it?

As technology and workplace expectations evolve, leaders are under increasing pressure to help their teams adapt without sacrificing performance.

But while technology changes rapidly, the human need for autonomy, competence, trust, and connection remains.

Doug's session was a reminder that effective leadership isn't simply about identifying problems and directing people toward solutions. It's about understanding what might be holding them back and creating the conditions for them to move forward.

The next time someone on your team becomes resistant, disengaged, or defensive, how might your response change if you approached their behavior with curiosity instead of frustration?

——

At Enrich, we bring experienced technology leaders together to work through real challenges, learn from one another, and develop the skills to become more effective leaders.

Want to join conversations like these? Apply to join Enrich.

Next
Next

Your AI Feature Is Live. So Why Isn't Anyone Using It?